Over ten years ago I was invited to a meeting where a major company wanted me to work with them in developing a link building project for their thousands of business clients. I reviewed the project and determined that it couldn’t be done PROPERLY because it would create patterns that ultimately would lead to penalization of their clients. So I walked away from a lucrative project. The problem with the SEO industry is that some major SEO agencies are willing to take the money and provide a poor service. How do I know? Because I am an independent web publisher and I get spammed by major SEO agencies. I make phone calls and investigate. I know who they are by name.

Knowledge is the best defense against poor SEO practioners.

Google has created an opportunity for poor SEO services that bring little to no value to the consumer. Google Webmaster Tools alerts small businesses about “unnatural links” which causes panicked businesses to seek out professional guidance. The problem is that the metrics used to judge how legit an SEO agency is (longevity in the business, list of notable past clients and conferences they have spoken at) are not a guarantee of quality service. Those are metrics that are easily fudged to create the appearance of competence. Here is why Google’s Penguin Algorithm is a gift to the SEO agencies: Delivering a Penguin recovery service is easy to do and it scales. Both of those ingredients, ease and scalability are essential for a process to service thousands of businesses and earn millions of dollars. Here is how it is done: A button is pushed on a service for reporting backlinks then another software button is used to identify email contacts which are collated into an email template which is then sent out to the owners of the domains, asking for the links to be taken down, both the good links and the bad links. Did you catch that? Legitimate links that help a site rank are being taken down along with the so-called bad links. This is why Penguin is a gift. It’s a simple process to scale while charging thousands of dollars.

But this process is even worse than that. The button pushing is outsourced to India. So while a business believes they are hiring a prestigious American or British firm, they are actually outsourcing to a shady company in India, the very thing a small business may be seeking to avoid. I personally know of several agencies that provide a good faith service. But I have been contacted by enough agencies to know that too many of them follow poor practices that are scalable which are outsourced to India. This is one of the dirty secrets of the SEO Industry. In order to service a large number of clients and maximize profits, large (and even some small) SEO agencies outsource the work to India.

Anytime I see the word “scalable” in an SEO article, a conference presentation or on an SEO website, what comes to mind is low quality and missed opportunities. Scalable is good for the SEO Agency and bad for the client. Scale allows an SEO Agency to take money from hundreds to thousands of small business clients while maintaining the PRETENSE of providing an agreed upon service.

What brings all this to mind is that I recently spoke with the CEO of a medium sized business who thought he was receiving top notch SEO from one of the most recognizable names in America. We all make mistakes. That’s understandable. But this particular SEO agency is not making a mistake. In my opinion they are willfully providing poor SEO services in order to feed the beast. I won’t out the SEO agency but I will say it’s one of the most recognizable names in SEO for over a decade, speaking at many SEO conferences. I contacted the business owner because I had received an email (in his name) asking for a legitimate link to be taken down. The timestamp on the email correlated with working hours in India. What’s going to happen is that this well known and “prestigious” SEO agency collected thousands of dollars to subcontract to a shady SEO in India who then turns around and collapses the client’s quality backlinks along with the “so-called” bad links. The SEO agency is destroying the quality backlink profile of a legitimate small business. This will leave the small business in an even worse situation because they will lose their organic rankings. While the SEO agency can claim it was the Indian subcontractor that is responsible, that agency should at the very least be monitoring the work to make sure their client isn’t being harmed.

I spoke to the owner of that small business and he related that they have never actively built links. Never. Their backlinks were the result of their good content. I didn’t discuss the nature of their penalty in enough detail but I suspect that Penguin was not their problem. One thing I am certain of, the work currently being performed for them will not likely have a positive outcome. How could it when their good links, the foundation of their online presence, is being dismantled along with their so-called bad links?

Ranking Factors vs. Characteristics of Sites that Rank

February 21, 2014

I was asked why a link from a non-profit dot org association was scored low by a popular third party Rank Metric tool. The site in question does not host links to bad neighborhoods. It does not engage in link building. It does not engage in any SEO practices whatsoever. It’s simply a clean site, [...]

Read the full article

How to Solve the Problem of Acquiring Natural Links

January 24, 2014

Fork-proof link building My focus on natural link building hinges on building awareness of your site/product in the minds of those likely to recommend it, either by word of mouth, social media, or links. Now more than ever the Internet Marketing Industry is considering it because of recent developments out of Google that is putting [...]

Read the full article

Why Marketing Matters… and Some Google Advice Matters Less

November 27, 2013

I saw a post on where members scoffed at the marketing advice in a Google AdSense newsletter. The newsletter recommended they advertise with AdWords.  I thought, “Hey, what do these twenty-something AdSense Googlers know about web publishing to advise US on how to market our websites?” I have visited the AdSense offices in Manhattan, Mountain [...]

Read the full article

What Google Keyword Data Removal Means

September 24, 2013

There’s discussion that the search encryption is related to hiding the data from the NSA. A little research shows that the truth of the matter may be something as simple as protecting user privacy, as Google asserts. It’s important to understand the reasons for things because it will inform your future decisions and making decisions with a sound footing is always preferable. Google says [...]

Read the full article

How to Launch an AdSense Business

September 16, 2013

We invariably get asked by friends and family for help in getting into the business. What follows is the advice I would give to anyone who is considering blogging online and monetizing their site with AdSense or affiliate work.  1. Domain name and copyright considerations First I’d like to start with the domain. You may want [...]

Read the full article

Why Google +1 is Not the Same as a Link

August 21, 2013

Interesting post over on the LocalSEOGuide blog titled,  Does Anyone Get And/Or Give Links Anymore? The author expresses the opinion that more and more new links are being shared from social media sites and less so from traditional sites and blogs. A similar observation was made last year by a Google engineer that people online [...]

Read the full article

How Search Engines Use Patterns to Identify Link Spam

August 7, 2013

Smoke Signals Where there is smoke, there’s an SEO fanning a fire. In the old days in-your-face signals like “Pay for a Link” language was enough to disqualify a link. Post-Penguin, more subtle signs of SEO are reason to pause and reconsider a link project.  When analyzing a web page for the purposes of identifying whether a link [...]

Read the full article

Post-Penguin Link Building for Newly Launched Sites

July 12, 2013

The bright side of launching a new site is you aren’t burdened with the cement shoes of SEO marketing. Throw on a leather sportcoat, put on the business suit, pull on your fishing waders. Anything but the SEO wardrobe. Get into the mind of who your site visitors are. That’s where the search engineers are at. 1. [...]

Read the full article

Link Campaign Tune-up

June 25, 2013

Link building can feel like digging a hole with a spoon. A common solution for improving results is to scale the process. But that’s digging a thousand holes with a thousand spoons. Scaling up does not necessarily address the issue at the heart of the problem: Low conversion rates. Conversion rates can be improved. A link campaign can become more effective when the following [...]

Read the full article